Crumbl Cookies is a chain of fresh-made cookies with over 300 locations in the United States. Last February, Crumbl Cookies opened its doors in Levittown, NY in Nassau Mall. Every week, Crumbl has a different lineup of 6 cookies that changes every week, but has some consistent fan-favorites such as chocolate chip that appear every week. The lines tend to go out the door weeks of popular flavors, such as this week, Crumbl’s birthday week! The Eagle’s Cry tries and reviews Crumbl’s birthday week menu!
Confetti Cake
Confetti cake is two fluffy tiers of cake batter confetti cake generously layered with smooth vanilla buttercream and crowned with a dash of vibrant rainbow sprinkles. Joe Ellinger said, “That cookie was terrible!” He compares the taste to a store-bought Twinkie. Tough crowd!
Milk Chocolate Chip
The classic fan-favorite. Stuffed with chocolate chips, this cookie never misses. Madison Lewin said, “This cookie is my go-to. It is great with a glass of milk.”
Birthday Cake featuring Oreo
A thick, delicious cookie loaded with Oreo cookie pieces, topped with creamy cake batter frosting, and sprinkled with even more Oreo bits and vibrant rainbow sprinkles. Perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth! However, when The Eagle’s Cry gave it a try, our cookie lacked the promised rainbow sprinkles.
Peanut Butter featuring Snickers
A rich peanut butter cookie loaded with chopped Snickers, topped with creamy caramel buttercream, sprinkled with even more Snickers pieces, and drizzled with smooth milk chocolate. Gianna Gravelli, a peanut butter lover, said, “This cookie was my overall favorite. I loved how it was served cold.”
Caramel Shortbread featuring Twix
A shortbread-inspired cookie loaded with Twix chunks, then topped with a layer of caramel, milk chocolate, and crunchy chopped Twix pieces. This one was my personal favorite! With Twix being my favorite candy, I was ecstatic to see this appear on the menu.
The Original Pink Sugar
The basic almond sugar cookie topped with pretty pink frosting is a Crumbl classic. Eva Neamonitis said, “I was unaware that there were almonds in this and I’m allergic. They should have a nut-free alternative or emphasize that they contain almonds.”
Despite objections, Crumbl Cookies are a great sweet treat. It’s fun to try the new flavors…so try them all?
